Counter 11 · Meatballs & Mince
Diner Meatloaf with Brown Gravy and Mash
A thick-sliced, onion-sweet beef meatloaf smothered in pan-drippings brown gravy and served over buttery mashed potatoes, just like the blue-plate special.
- Prep
- 20 min
- Cook
- 1 hr 15 min
- Serves
- 6
- Level
- Easy
Diner meatloaf skips the ketchup glaze and leans on gravy instead, which means the loaf needs to be deeply seasoned on its own. Sauteing the onion first takes the raw bite away and adds sweetness, and a panade of saltines and milk keeps slices moist days later. Bake it free-form on a sheet pan instead of a loaf tin: more surface browns, and the drippings collect for the gravy. Slice it thick, about an inch, so it holds under the ladle.
Method
Members counter
This one is behind the counter.
The full method for Diner Meatloaf with Brown Gravy and Mash is part of membership. Join for $14.99 a month or $114.99 a year and every recipe on the board opens up, including this one.
Already a member? Sign in. Or browse free recipes.


11 Hanging next to it
All Meatballs & Mince →
Members only
No. 11 · Meatballs & Mince
Kousa Mahshi Stuffed Zucchini
4.7 (156)
Members only
No. 11 · Meatballs & Mince
Icli Kofte on Garlic Yogurt
4.9 (118)
Free
No. 11 · Meatballs & Mince
Egg-Stuffed Meatloaf with Buttered Potatoes
4.5 (159)
Members only
No. 11 · Meatballs & Mince
Stuffed Red Pepper with Paprika Tomato Sauce
4.5 (204)